Menu Prize Mystery #1 CGC 3.5 1955 4707363002
Grade CGC 3.5 Page Quality Off white Year 1955 Publisher Key Publications
Any CGC case may have cosmetic imperfections including scuffs, scratches, standard surface wear, minor cracks, or Newton rings. We will not list for sale any slabbed comic with a damaged case that compromises the integrity of the grade.
Description
Stories and art by Eugene E. Hughes and others. Fanciful mystery stories with an added cash incentive for the lucky 1950s reader. Inmates attempt a daring escape from an island prison that no prisoner has ever escaped. A two-page mystery involving murder at a circus offers a cash prize to the reader who can figure it out - the "prize" of the magazine's title. High-ranking US military officials learn a scientist has invented a time machine, but brings bad tidings from the future. Escape; Lie Detector!; The Circus Caper; Marked Weapon!; Hold Back Time; Pardon! 32 pages, Full Color.
This item is a consignment
This item is a consignment, which means that the price has been set by the consignor rather than by MyComicShop. It is located at our headquarters and ships just as quickly as everything else we carry.
Grading & Packing
We take pride in our accurate, consistent grading. You can be confident in receiving a well-graded comic when ordering from us.
We understand that condition is important to collectors. We pack your comics with professional care and high-quality packaging to insure your purchase reaches you safely.
About Us
We opened our first comic retail store in 1977 and operated a chain of eight comic book stores in the 80s, 90s, and 2000s before going online-only. We are the world's largest comic book seller and the biggest and most trusted comic seller on with over 3.6 million comics sold.
We Buy & Consign
We buy tens of thousands of comics every month from collections large and small, old and new. We also accept consignments and will get your comics listed on for you. Check out our website for more info.
Copyright © 2026 MyComicShop & Lone Star Comics. All rights reserved.
Related Items:
Prize Mystery (1955) #2 Key Publications Horror Sal Trapani Eugene Hughes GD+
$27.50
Prize Mystery #1 CGC 3.5 1955 4707363002
$345.00
Prize Comics #45 Prize Publications 9/44 CGC .5 Dick Briefer and Fred Morgan
$100.00
